VGChartz’s Daniel Parker: “Overall, there’s too much wrong with Sonic Superstars. Despite the platforming physics being fine, and some of the soundtrack fantastic, it’s simply not worth the asking price. You’d be better off listening to the game’s soundtrack on YouTube while playing the far superior Sonic Mania instead. Younger children might find some enjoyment here, but it’s not a game for everyone – and definitely not one for me. Sonic Superstars is ultimately nothing short of a major letdown.”