VGChartz’s Lee Mehr: “To put In Nightmare into perspective: imagine leeches sucking enthusiasm out of your body the longer you play. Yes, it’s functional and has some decent concepts, however the experience simply can’t avoid comparisons with boring indie horror titles. Even its small gameplay nuances wind up detracting from engagement in multifaceted ways. It’s through all of these considerations – big and small – that Magic Fish Studio’s first title comfortably ranks among the worst I’ll play all year.”